Files
octoturge 0da354f040 Record the HTTP client continuum-proxy took, and the one it could not
`reqwest` was added to continuum-proxy so a gateway can download a job file
from a presigned URL. Everything it brings is permissive and verified from
`cargo metadata`; the entry lists each crate so the next person does not have
to re-derive it.

The useful half is the rejection. reqwest 0.13's `rustls` feature pulls
`webpki-root-certs` under CDLA-Permissive-2.0 and `cargo deny` refuses it.
That licence is in fact permissive and could reasonably be added to the
table - but it is a *data* licence on a certificate bundle, which is a
different question from a code licence, and waving it through to unblock a
dependency bump is how a policy stops meaning anything. Recorded as a
deliberate open question rather than silently allowed or silently forgotten.
The other 0.13 route brings `aws-lc` and its OpenSSL-licensed C, which is
simply out.

Also noted: rustls here does not remove `openssl-sys` from the tree. It is
still there via the `native-tls` that the Bambu MQTT and FTPS clients use, so
nobody should read this entry as "the proxy no longer links OpenSSL".
2026-10-15 22:54:26 +00:00

218 lines
11 KiB
Markdown

# Licence policy
Continuum is a closed-source commercial product. We intend to sell it, so
every dependency must permit distribution in proprietary software without
publishing our own source. This document is the policy; `deny.toml` in each
repo is the machine-enforced half of it.
## The rule
**Permissive only.** A dependency is allowed if it is one of:
| Licence | Notes |
| --- | --- |
| MIT, ISC, 0BSD, BSD-2-Clause, BSD-3-Clause | The common case |
| Apache-2.0 (incl. `WITH LLVM-exception`) | Carries a patent grant, which is a plus |
| Unlicense, CC0-1.0 | Public-domain dedications |
| Zlib, BlueOak-1.0.0 | Permissive, OSI/Blue Oak approved |
| Unicode-3.0 | Unicode data tables |
| MPL-2.0 | File-level copyleft only; fine as long as we do not edit the dependency's own files |
**Forbidden, no exceptions:** GPL, LGPL (when statically linked), AGPL, SSPL,
RSAL, Commons Clause, "source available", CC-BY-NC, and any licence with a
field-of-use or non-commercial restriction.
Two rules that are easy to get wrong:
- **Dual-licensed dependencies are fine** - we elect the permissive option.
Record the election here so it is not re-litigated (see `node-forge` below).
- **LGPL is conditionally fine** but only via *dynamic* linking with the
library replaceable by the user. Rust static linking does not qualify.
Assume LGPL is forbidden unless someone writes down why a specific case
is not.
## How it is enforced
Rust, per repo:
```sh
cargo deny check licenses # proxy, ai-worker
cargo deny --manifest-path packages/rust-core/Cargo.toml check licenses # common, schemas
cargo deny --manifest-path apps/desktop/src-tauri/Cargo.toml check licenses # app
```
Our own crates declare `license = "LicenseRef-Proprietary"` with
`publish = false`. `LicenseRef-Proprietary` is deliberately *not* a real SPDX
identifier and must never be added to a `deny.toml` allow list - a
third-party crate claiming it would be a genuine finding, and `publish =
false` is what marks ours as first-party. Our npm packages use
`"license": "UNLICENSED"` with `"private": true`, which is npm's equivalent
convention.
JavaScript has no `cargo deny` equivalent wired up yet; the audit below was
done by walking installed `node_modules` manifests.
## What the tooling cannot see
`cargo deny` only reads the cargo graph. Three categories sit outside it and
have to be checked by hand:
1. **External binaries we spawn or ship.** Invoking a GPL program as a
separate process is not itself a derivative work, but *shipping* it in our
installer means distributing it under its own terms.
2. **ML model weights.** A model's licence is independent of the runtime that
loads it. This is the single biggest trap in this project (see
`continuum-ai-worker` below).
3. **Managed/self-hosted services.** The client library's licence is not the
server's licence. `ioredis` being MIT says nothing about Redis.
## Audit, 2026-09-17 (Redis resolved 2026-10-03)
All six repos audited. **No copyleft code is currently compiled into any
Continuum binary.** Every Rust crate across `continuum-proxy`,
`continuum-ai-worker`, `continuum-app/apps/desktop`, `continuum-common` and
`continuum-schemas` passes the policy above. The JS graphs are MIT/Apache/ISC/
BSD/BlueOak throughout.
Fixed in this pass: all six of our own crates and all nine of our npm
packages were missing a licence field (`cargo deny` reported them as
`unlicensed` errors), and no repo had a `deny.toml`.
### Findings carried forward
**Redis - RESOLVED 2026-10-03, we use Valkey.** Redis 7.4+ is RSALv2/SSPLv1
and Redis 8.0+ added AGPLv3 as a third option. All three are non-permissive,
and SSPL §13 specifically targets offering the software's functionality as a
service - which is what a cloud control plane does. The *clients* were never
the problem (`ioredis` and the `redis` crate are both MIT); the server we
deploy was.
We now deploy **Valkey** (BSD-3-Clause, Linux Foundation, forked from Redis
7.2.4). What changed: `REDIS_URL` -> `VALKEY_URL` and
`CONTINUUM_REDIS_URL` -> `CONTINUUM_VALKEY_URL`, the exported `redis` client
in `continuum-backend/src/queue/` renamed to `valkey`, `Config.redis_url` ->
`Config.valkey_url` in `continuum-ai-worker`, `/health` now reports a
`valkey` field, and `continuum-backend/docker-compose.yml` pins
`valkey/valkey:8-alpine`. Both tiers still typecheck/compile unchanged
otherwise, because Valkey speaks the same protocol.
Two things deliberately did **not** change, so nobody "fixes" them later:
the `redis://` URL scheme (it names the RESP wire protocol, and no client
library understands a `valkey://` scheme), and the client libraries
themselves (`ioredis`, the `redis` crate) - they are RESP clients, and their
names refer to the protocol's origin, not to the server we run.
**AI model weights - blocks `PLAN.md` step 4.** `src/inference/mod.rs`
currently stubs a `"spaghetti"` detection. The two obvious off-the-shelf
sources are both **AGPL-3.0**: Ultralytics YOLO (v5/v8/v11) and Obico / The
Spaghetti Detective's print-failure model. Neither can ship in a commercial
product without a paid enterprise licence. The `ort` crate itself is MIT and
fine. Permissive alternatives to evaluate when step 4 comes up: YOLOX
(Apache-2.0), RT-DETR (Apache-2.0), RF-DETR (Apache-2.0), or training our own
weights on a permissively-licensed architecture. **Decide the architecture
before collecting training data** - retraining because of a licence is the
expensive version of this mistake.
**go2rtc and ffmpeg - currently fine, keep it that way.**
`continuum-proxy/src/go2rtc.rs` spawns go2rtc (MIT) from `PATH` and expects
the operator to have installed it, so we distribute nothing. If that ever
changes: go2rtc shells out to ffmpeg, and ffmpeg is LGPL-2.1+ *only* when
built without `--enable-gpl`. Most distro and prebuilt ffmpeg binaries are
GPL builds (they bundle x264). Shipping one would be a GPL distribution.
**`node-forge` - dual-licensed, we elect BSD-3-Clause.** It appears in
`continuum-app` as `(BSD-3-Clause OR GPL-2.0)`. The election is ours to make
and is recorded here so the GPL half does not trigger a false alarm later.
**`caniuse-lite` - CC-BY-4.0, attribution required if redistributed.** A
build-time browserslist dependency in `continuum-app`; its data is not
bundled into the Nuxt output, so no attribution obligation today. It would
acquire one if anything started shipping the dataset itself.
**Infrastructure already clear.** PostgreSQL and pgvector (PostgreSQL
licence), PgBouncer (ISC), pgCat (MIT), Supabase (Apache-2.0), ONNX Runtime
(MIT), Cloudflare R2 (a service, governed by contract not licence) all
permit commercial use.
### Not findings
A `node_modules` walk turns up packages named `baz`, `browser_field`,
`invalid_main`, `false_main` and `nw-pre-gyp-module-test` with no licence
field. These are test fixtures *inside* other packages, not dependencies.
Ignore them.
## Audit, 2026-10-15 - continuum-proxy dual-licence elections
Found while adding a zip reader to `continuum-proxy` (see below). All three
were already in the tree, all three pass `cargo deny check licenses`, and
none had its election recorded - which rule one at the top of this document
says to do, so that a `grep` for "GPL" does not restart the argument.
Verified from `cargo metadata`, not from memory.
**`unescaper` 0.1.10 - `MIT OR GPL-3.0-only`, we elect MIT.** Reached via
`tokio-serial` -> `serialport` -> `unescaper`, so it is in the Linux build.
The MIT half is ours to take.
**`r-efi` 6.0.0 - `MIT OR Apache-2.0 OR LGPL-2.1-or-later`, we elect MIT or
Apache-2.0.** Reached via `native-tls` -> `tempfile` -> `getrandom`, but only
on UEFI targets: it is not compiled for any platform we ship. The LGPL option
would be the problem one if it ever were, and electing around it is free.
**`serialport` 4.10.0 - MPL-2.0, allowed with a condition.** The table above
permits MPL-2.0 because its copyleft is per-file, which holds only while we
do not edit the dependency's own files. We do not and should not: if
`serialport` ever needs a patch, vendor the change as a fork with its own
notice, or wrap it, rather than editing files in place.
**An HTTP client in `continuum-proxy`, and the version we could not take.**
Added 2026-10-15 so a gateway can download a job file from a presigned URL.
The choice is `reqwest` 0.12.28 with `default-features = false` and
`rustls-tls-native-roots`, and the version matters:
- **reqwest 0.13 is out.** Its `rustls` feature pulls
`rustls-platform-verifier` -> `webpki-root-certs` under
**CDLA-Permissive-2.0**, which is not in the table above, and
`cargo deny` rejects it outright (`error[rejected]: license is not
explicitly allowed`). CDLA-Permissive-2.0 is in fact a permissive licence
and could reasonably be added - but it is a *data* licence applied to a
certificate bundle, which is a different question from a code licence and
deserves a deliberate decision rather than being waved through to unblock
a dependency bump. Left out until someone wants it.
- The other 0.13 route brings `aws-lc`, which contains OpenSSL-licensed C.
Also out.
What 0.12 with that feature set brings, all verified from `cargo metadata`
rather than from memory, and all permissive: `reqwest` 0.12.28, `hyper`
1.12.0, `hyper-util` 0.1.21, `http-body` 1.1.0, `tower` 0.5.3,
`tower-service` 0.3.3 (all MIT); `rustls` 0.23.46, `hyper-rustls` 0.27.10,
`rustls-native-certs` 0.8.5 (`Apache-2.0 OR ISC OR MIT`); `rustls-webpki`
0.103.15 and `untrusted` 0.9.0 (ISC); `ring` 0.17.14
(**`Apache-2.0 AND ISC`** - note the AND: both apply, and both are fine);
`sync_wrapper` 1.0.2 (Apache-2.0); `subtle` 2.6.1 (BSD-3-Clause);
`zerocopy` 0.8.56 (`BSD-2-Clause OR Apache-2.0 OR MIT`); plus `http`,
`httparse`, `base64`, `url`, `ipnet`, `rustls-pki-types` and `tokio-rustls`
(`MIT OR Apache-2.0`).
`openssl-probe` 0.2.1 appears and is only a certificate-path lookup, no C.
Note that `openssl-sys` is still in the tree regardless, via the existing
`native-tls` the Bambu MQTT and FTPS clients use - rustls here does not
remove it.
**New in `continuum-proxy` on 2026-10-15, all clear:** `zip` 9.0.3 (MIT),
`flate2` 1.1.10, `crc32fast` 1.5.2, `typed-path` 0.12.3 (all
`MIT OR Apache-2.0`), `miniz_oxide` 0.9.1 (`MIT OR Zlib OR Apache-2.0`),
`adler2` 2.0.1 (`0BSD OR MIT OR Apache-2.0`), `simd-adler32` 0.3.10 (MIT),
`zlib-rs` 0.6.8 (Zlib). Added for reading `.3mf` project archives. The
feature set is deliberately `deflate-flate2` only - `zip`'s other codec
features pull in bzip2, lzma/xz and zstd bindings, none of which are needed
and each of which is another licence to check. Confirmed none of them entered
the graph.
## When adding a dependency
1. Check the licence against the table above **before** writing code against
it. Replacing a library after it is load-bearing is the costly path.
2. Run the repo's `cargo deny check licenses`.
3. If it is an external binary, a model, or a service, none of the tooling
will catch it - add it to the audit section above by hand.